Comic Reviews

Ultimate Spider-Man #12: Comic Book Review

In this review of Ultimate Spider-Man #12, it’s Christmas in New York and the Parkers are having a grand family gathering. But is everything as it seems?  

 

ultimate spider-man #12 main cover
Ultimate Spider-Man #12 main cover by Marco Checchetto

Ultimate Spider-Man #12
Writer:
Jonathan Hickman
Art and Main Cover: Marco Checchetto
Variant Cover Artists: Pepe Larraz Jeehyung Lee, Paco Medina
Page Count: 28 pages
Release Date: December 18, 2024

 

This comic book review contains spoilers 

 

The Story

Ultimate Spider-Man #12 begins as Jonah and Ben arrive at Peter’s to find a whole host of familiar faces. There’s Peter, MJ, Richard, and May of course, and also MJ’s Aunt Anna, her sister Gayle, and her mother Madeline. 

Madeline takes the part of family agitator as she gives MJ crap for catering instead of cooking and comments on Ben Parker’s bachelor status. Then it’s Gayle’s turn to take the mantle as she attempts to guilt trip May for not remembering her despite never being around, before getting into it with MJ over disparaging comments Gayle made about Peter. MJ gets a phone call from Gwen which she declines. 

Soon separate groups start to coagulate around the apartment. By the Christmas tree, Anna tells Ben and Madeline that Gayle is getting divorced and Madeline floats the idea of moving in with Anna much to Anna’s dismay. In the kitchen, MJ vents to Peter about her sister. Meanwhile in the den, JJ imparts some invaluable wisdom about the pursuit of love to Richard which boils down to: fake it til you make it.

Finally, fed up, MJ pulls her sister into a corner and demands they squash the beef. Gayle informs her that her husband has been having an ongoing affair and they’re getting a divorce. She begrudgingly apologizes to MJ for the things she’s said and they embrace. MJ declines another call from Gwen. 

JJ asks Ben if he would have a chance with MJ’s mom and he tells him to go for it. Now, with all family animosity quelled, they take a group picture and Ben declares it a great year. 

The End. 

Or is it? 

Ultimate Spider-Man #12 ends with an epilogue shows MJ getting a final call from Gwen. She answers this time. Gwen says Harry has been missing for six days and no one’s been able to reach him. MJ asks Peter if he knows where Harry could be but he doesn’t answer. When MJ reaches out to grab him, his skin morphs into a black symbiotic substance. He turns around to reveal solid black eyes and a devilish smile. Elsewhere, the real Peter and Harry are chained up, hooked to green IVs with a mammothine Kraven hovering over them. 

 

Analysis 

Here it is. Jonathan Hickman and Marco Checchetto give us the best Christmas present a comic book fan could ask for: An absolute stunner of a conclusion to one of this year’s best comics. Let’s start with the cover. Checchetto and Wilson have been killing it with the covers all year and this one might just be my favorite. Yes it’s clickbait, and the kids will be bummed but c‘mon, Spider-Man dressed up as Santa Claus delivering plush kingpins out of a big green sack? We’ve gotta get that story one day. 

As has become common with this run, there is virtually no action to be found here. Just airtight character writing, Hickman’s warm as a blanket family dynamics, and Checchetto’s wonderfully detailed and dynamic artwork. 

Hickman takes the holiday issue of Ultimate Spider-Man #12 as an opportunity to flesh out lesser known characters like Gayle and Madeline Watson. Only the most erudite Spidey-super fans will recognize them at all, and their effectively being a blank slate means Hickman is able to take major creative liberties. For example, this iteration of Madeline Watson most noticeably recalls Lady Caroline Collingwood from HBO’s Succession in both appearance and behavior. It’s a fairly logical contrast to MJ’s more lax demeanor and works well to create conflict during the issues’ slower moments. The dynamic between MJ and her sister is one I’m sure many fans will relate with, and their eventual reconciliation is handled with maturity and deft. 

To sum up what makes Ultimate Spider-Man #12 so special: it feels like visiting family. Warts and all. It’s not the first issue of Ultimate Spider-Man to feel this way. I don’t want to oversell it but that signals to me that Hickman is transcending Spider-Man with this book. It taps into something deeper, something more real. There is not a comic that captures the slice of life family drama better than Ultimate Spider-Man, and that’s kind of a crazy thing to say. 

“Happiness is being surrounded by the people you love.” 

Hitchcock once talked about the difference between suspense and surprise. Suspense is when we know there is a bomb under the table that’s going to explode but the characters don’t. Surprise is when we’re just as in the dark as they are until it explodes. Ultimate Spider-Man #12 decidedly takes the latter approach and it works terrifically. We spend the entire issue waiting for a shoe to drop: could this really just be another hangout issue with no superheroics like we’ve gotten twice before in this run?

Just when it seems Hickman has given us a sweet family issue for Christmas with Ultimate Spider-Man #12, boom! He wallops us with a twist that he’s been subtly building towards for the last few months. I didn’t even realize until my second reading that Peter doesn’t say a word until the very end. 

“Fear is knowing it can all be taken away.” 

I think Kraven with the mohawk and face tats is the coolest design I’ve seen. Coming from someone who has absolutely loved the relatively low stakes, wholesome joy of these last 12 issues, after the events of Ultimate Spider-Man #12, I’m ready for the 2025 arc to go full Empire Strikes Back. Let’s get dark. 

 

Final Thoughts

Ultimate Spider-Man #12 is a brilliant Christmas present from Jonathan Hickman and Marco Checchetto, and a beautiful closer to one of the absolute best comics of 2024.

 

Marvel Comics provided The Comic Book Spot with an advanced copy of Ultimate Spider-Man #12 for review purposes. Find more reviews here. You can find this comic and help support us in the process by ordering this issue digitally on Amazon or a physical copy of the title through Things From Another World.

Ultimate Spider-Man #12
Final Thoughts
Ultimate Spider-Man #12 is a brilliant Christmas present from Jonathan Hickman and Marco Checchetto, and a beautiful closer to one of the absolute best comics of 2024. 
10
Final Score
Support The Comic Book Spot by Purchasing from our Affiliates

Related posts

Comic Review: The Amazing Spider-Man #65

Miles Weeks

Comic Review: Narco #4

beastfire

Comic Review: Fall of the House Of Slaughter #2

beastfire