Comic Reviews

Avengers #1 Review: The Ghosts of One More Day Haunt Zdarsky’s Debut

In this review of Avengers #1, NYC is attacked by mysterious extra-dimensional forces, compelling a problematic team to band together and protect it.

 

Avengers #1 main cover by Marco Checchetto (Marvel Comics)
Avengers #1 main cover by Marco Checchetto (Marvel Comics)

AVENGERS #1
Written by: Chip Zdarsky
Art and Main Cover: Marco Checchetto
Variant Covers: David Nakayama, Julian Totino Tedesco, Kaare Andrews,Pascal Garcin, Skottie Young, Stanley Lau, Ryan Stegman, Jim Cheung, Rose Besch, Chip Zdarsky
Page Count: 37 pages
Release Date: November 4, 2026

 

This review contains spoilers

Avengers #1 by Chip Zdarsky and Marco Checchetto follows the events of Captain America #16, in which Dr. Doom takes Mephisto’s place as the ruler of Hell, and the conclusion of Avengers: Armageddon #5, in which the use of superpowers was banned by the UN—except in America—courtesy of the Red Hulk’s nuclear explosion. 

We pick up with the Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man swinging around, checking in on Aunt May. She does not remember him following the events of The Amazing Spider-Man #1000, where Ravage erased her memories. Meanwhile, Captain Marvel is depressed at Josie’s. She’s reeling from her failure to stop Ross, and implying self-annihilation when she is consoled by Daredevil. Elsewhere, Mayor Luke Cage is dealing with the fallout of superhero hate, and Wolverine takes a sabbatical from the X-Men to go check on David Colton, who now holds the powers of Miracleman. Colton is invading Stark Tower for answers.

Spider-Man goes to stop him, but gets pummeled. He lets go of his restraints and knocks Dave back. Their fight is broken up both by Wolverine and winged-beings attacking civilians. The assaults are sent by Dr. Doom, whose first order as ruler of Hell was to make sure that Mephisto’s deals were nullified. Consequently, people who gained life through Mephisto must now lose it.

page from Avengers #1 showing Spider-Man and Luke Cage speaking
Something is coming, Mr. Mayor… (Marvel Comics)

Two parents recognize what’s happening and imply they dealt with Mephisto to save the life of their daughter, Paige Howley. The dad leaves her with a grimoire named Grimsby and instructs her to run, before fighting Doom’s forces. Grimsby informs her of the reason for the attack.

Spider-Man, Miracleman, and Wolverine are joined by Luke Cage, Daredevil, and Captain Marvel to fight back the demons. Matt and Carol were about to share a kiss before joining the fight. Luke Cage discovers using the demons’ swords against them is the key to victory. 

At the end of the issue, Spider-Man and Daredevil save Paige, who was told by Grimsby that Spider-Man’s deal with Mephisto to save May Parker is going to lead to May’s death. Peter is initially confused, before stating he’s always had a feeling about such a deal existing, alluding to the events of One More Day. Spidey’s pained expression at the realization through his torn mask tells it all as the winged-beings descend on May.

Analysis

The first thing I want to talk about is that I get the vibe that the main character of this Avengers run is Spider-Man. He got the most focus and said the line that’s reminiscent of “Avengers Assemble”. Spidey was also the centerpiece of Tony’s vision with Mephisto in Armageddon #5. It paints the picture that an Avengers story is going to mainly be told through the lens of Spider-Man. And I personally love it. 

I was expecting Carol, but for all the recent comics we’ve had where she was a leader—which I think were well-done— putting her in a new role where she’s unlike her usual optimistic and put-together self is interesting. And letting someone like Spider-Man step up to the plate and potentially bat as the leader is awesome. It’s new, it’s different, and it’s doing well to capitalize on his re-emerging popularity following Brand New Day.

Zdarsky, you really wanted to make a great first impression for a memorable Avengers run? Well, starting out by confronting arguably the most polarizing Spider-Man story ever–in One More Day– is a great place to begin. I have no idea where this will go, but I don’t want to make any guesses because I trust Zdarsky to take me on this ride. I’ll sail these waters with him as my captain, the same way I did with Avengers: Armageddon, because he rarely disappoints.

As for the aforementioned Carol Danvers, the panel with her lifeless stare in the midst of the nuke is horrifying and one that will stick with me. The powerful Captain Marvel watching everything–including people–go up in flames while she’s powerless to stop it is visually and thematically striking. No wonder she was willing to go down such a dark path at Josie’s.

Lastly, as a Jessica Jones fanboy, I’m glad she got an appearance where she actually got to contribute to the story. I hope there’s more of that through Luke Cage. When the Avengers need a hand, she can run these little side missions where she’s being a detective. Alias: Red Band was really good, so I’m glad to see her back in the fray.

Final Thoughts

Despite Zdarsky’s body of work, I was initially unsure about this run because this group of characters seemed like a disjointed fit. Safe to say, I was gladly wrong, and I’m strapped in to see these characters grow as a team.

Avengers #1 cover

Avengers #1

Marvel Comics Reviewed by
Rating Score
8.8

Creative Team

Story Chip Zdarsky
Art Marco Checchetto
Cover Marco Checchetto

Final Thoughts

Despite Zdarsky’s body of work, I was initially unsure about this run because this group of characters seemed like a disjointed fit. Safe to say, I was gladly wrong, and I’m strapped in to see these characters grow as a team.

Related posts

Comic Review: Event Horizon: Dark Descent #5

beastfire

The Smart Division #1 Comic Review

Adam Koppel

New Avengers #9 Comic Book Review

Adam Koppel